#1
Skye Avenue Kitchen + Lounge
Top PickLocal independent
A modern Surrey dining spot known for polished Italian-inspired dishes and a lively lounge atmosphere. It stands out for its elevated presentation and strong local following.
Surrey, BC · Top 5 list
The Best Italian Restaurants in Surrey
Our independently researched top 5 italian restaurants serving Surrey, British Columbia — ranked by Google ratings, review volume, and local reputation.
Last updated May 2026 · How we rank
#2
Saba Bistro
Local independent
An intimate neighborhood Italian restaurant that emphasizes classic recipes and a warm, personal dining experience. It is a local favorite for pizza, pasta, and relaxed dinners.
#3
Cotto Al Mare
Local independent
A contemporary Italian restaurant focused on fresh ingredients and a refined coastal style of cooking. It stands out for its modern menu and design-forward dining room.
#4
Boston Pizza
A well-known casual chain offering Italian-American comfort food, pizza, and family-friendly service. It makes the list as a high-review-count option in Surrey, though it is not locally independent.
#5
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
A large North American chain known for reliable pasta dishes, salad, and breadsticks. It ranks here as a recognizable option, but it is less locally distinctive than independent Surrey restaurants.